At That Point
  • home
  • services
  • about us
  • our work
  • our thoughts
  • SAIPA Newsroom

Understanding the true cost of Financial Emigration

8/10/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
Whilst financial emigration may be a viable option for a small minority of individuals, for the majority, it’s likely to be a costly exercise which won’t in the long-term provide significant tax relief.

Authored by: Ettiene Retief, Chairman of the National Tax and SARS Committee at the South African Institute of Professional Accountants (SAIPA).

Recent news reports have provided conflicting – and even wholly inaccurate – information around the implications for expats to the scheduled March 2020 change to the Income Tax Act. Alarmingly, a number of tax practitioners and financial advisors have been recommending that people financially emigrate in order to avoid the expat tax the revised Act has implemented. And while financial emigration is a viable option for a small minority of individuals, for the majority it’s likely to be a costly exercise which won’t in the long-term provide significant tax relief.

What exactly is financial emigration? Financial emigration is the process whereby taxpayers change their status with the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) from resident to non-resident. It’s a process conducted purely for exchange control purposes, but which does not affect your citizenship status in any way.

Emigration, on the other hand, is a very different process as it involves physically relocating from one country to another country either in the short or long term. Once emigration has become a permanent status, the process of financially emigrating – during which time the individual’s assets move from their old country of residence to their new country of residence – takes place.

The mistake many people are currently making is that they are expecting financial emigration to resolve their issues around paying tax in South Africa on income earned abroad, a so-called ‘expat tax’. The reality, however, is that financial emigration for most individuals won’t provide material tax savings.

Historical context
It’s not uncommon in this modern era to find individuals who have primary residence in one country but who work and earn income in at least one other country. The question is, where do they pay tax?

There has been a global acceptance that it’s not fair to expect individuals to pay tax in both their country of residence and in the country in which they earned the income. As a result – and in order to relieve the burden of paying double tax – it became acceptable practice that the country in which the income was earned has the right to charge tax, in which case the income then became exempt from tax in the individual’s country of residence, or the country of residence provided a credit for the tax paid in another country.

Section 10(1) (o) (ii) of the Income Tax Act is the section which provides this particular tax exemption to South African expats on their foreign income. The proviso, however, is that they need to be outside the country for a total of more than 183 days, of which at least 60 days are consecutive days in any 12-month period. Individuals who met these conditions were effectively exempt from paying tax on their income in South Africa.

However, while the exemption clause was intended to protect individuals from being doubly taxed, it was never intended to relieve taxpayers of double non-taxation. The reality, however, is that some individuals are using this clause to avoid paying tax in any jurisdiction. The United Arab Emirates, for example, has no direct tax requirements in place. South African expats working there could, therefore, in theory, avoid paying any tax at all, whilst still retaining their South African residency.

In response to this trend, the South African Revenue Service (SARS) announced that it intended removing this exemption but as a result of public pressure, has agreed to delay its removal until March 2020.

Understanding the changes to the Income Tax Act
Once the amendments to the Income Tax Act come into effect in March 2020, South African tax residents working abroad will only be exempt from paying tax on the first R1 million they earn abroad. Thereafter they will be required to pay tax on any foreign earnings.

The revised Act does, however, make provision for expats working abroad who are registered for tax in those countries. In these instances, the Act allows those individuals to apply for credits in South Africa which are offset against the tax they owe locally, with the tax rate starting at the lowest rate.

The reality, therefore, is that South Africans working abroad will in most instances not be significantly negatively impacted by the changed regulations and will still not be doubly taxed. The only individuals that will be detrimentally impacted are those earning very large amounts offshore and even in these instances, they will still only be paying the same amount of tax they would have been paying in South Africa in any event.

What’s important to understand is that to all intents and purposes the law has not changed but has instead just corrected a loophole.

It would be counter-intuitive to allow South African residents who spend the majority of their time in the country and have the majority of their assets here, to avoid paying tax locally. South Africa’s tax regime is based on a residence-based system and is evaluated according to how much time you spend in the country, where your assets are based, where your family resides most of the time, and where the country in which your primary residence is situated.

South African residents who work abroad permanently and spend the majority of their time living abroad would already be considered non-residents from a tax perspective. Remember that it is possible to change your tax residency without having to financially emigrate.

When is financial emigration a good idea?
While financial emigration is not a means of avoiding the expat tax, there are limited circumstances when it is a viable option. A viable reason for emigrating financially is in order to access your retirement funding earlier or to shift an inheritance offshore. However, what an individual should not forget is that it is possible to make use of the R10 million foreign investment allowance without having to financially emigrate.

Now that foreign income above R1 million is no longer exempt from tax, the authorities are concerned not just with income earned abroad, but also the value of fringe benefits, including accommodation, which the individual has received. The addition of fringe benefits can quickly launch an individual over the R1 million threshold. This is something of a contentious issue, particularly if the taxpayer is working in a developing country and is subjected to very basic, but often fairly costly, accommodation, which you are then taxed on.

A SARS tax compliance certificate is required should an individual decide to emigrate. There are three types of compliance certificates that an individual can apply for.

These are as follows:
  • Certificate of Good Standing: This compliance status is issued when a taxpayer wants to confirm that their tax affairs are in order with SARS.
  • Foreign Investment Allowance: This compliance status is issued when a taxpayer will be investing funds outside of South Africa. Foreign Investment Allowance applications are only available to individuals older than 18 years of age.
  • Emigration: This compliance status is required when a taxpayer will be permanently leaving South Africa to reside in another country and can only be selected if the eFiler is registered for Income Tax and is an individual. Emigrating from South Africa formalises an individual’s exit from South Africa for exchange control purposes. It does not mean that the individual will have to relinquish his/her South African citizenship. The individual may retain his/her South African passport.

There are downsides to financial emigration

What recent news reports encouraging individuals to emigrate financially in order to avoid the expat tax have failed to reveal is that financial emigration is an expensive exercise. There is a huge tax implication involved in changing an individual’s tax residency.

By financially emigrating an individual is deemed to have disposed of all their assets in South Africa, which means that capital gains tax starts applying. Should the individual decide at some future point to financially emigrate back to South Africa, the individual would not get that money back.

To avoid South African taxation rules, an individual would need to first change their tax residency – financial emigration is the very last step and even then, it’s not an essential part of an amended tax residency given that it is only an exchange control provision. Emigration and financial emigration only comfortably overlap when a taxpayer is legitimately emigrating. The latter doesn’t work if the individual intends to continue residing in South Africa.

Conclusion

Before deciding to financially emigrate the individual taxpayer must make sure all the facts are at hand. Understand the cost and long-term implications and carefully consider these before deciding on this route. The individual taxpayer must be certain that it is a permanent move. Does the individual have a long-term visa, a residency permit or is being sponsored to put down roots in a different country? To financially emigrate as a South African resident in order to avoid a small amount of tax is probably not a wise decision.

Even if the taxpayer is legitimately emigrating, they shouldn’t financially emigrate until they are totally convinced that this is a long-term decision. Individuals should also be particularly wary of service providers offering to help with financial emigration who don’t mention the significant cost associated with this. Those individuals that are considering pursuing the financial emigration route should take the time to understand the real cost implications and do their homework thoroughly.

ENDS

MEDIA CONTACT: Stephné du Toit, 084 587 9933, stephne@thatpoint.co.za, www.atthatpoint.co.za  
For more information on SAIPA please visit:
Website: www.saipa.co.za
Twitter: @SAIPAcomms
LinkedIn: South African Institute of Professional Accountants Company
Facebook: South African Institute of Professional Accountants
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Welcome to the SAIPA newsroom. For releases prior to August 2014 please click here.

    Archives

    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014

    Categories

    All
    2014/15 Tax Filing Season
    2016 Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill
    21 February 2018
    4IR
    Accountability
    Accountancy
    Accountants
    Accounting
    Accounting Ethics
    Accounting Institutions
    Accounting Integrity
    Accounting Standards
    Advice For Professional Accountants
    Africa
    Anti-corruption Pledge
    B-BBEEE
    Blockchain
    Bongani Coka
    Brian Purcell
    Bridging The Gap
    Budget 2015
    Budget 2016/17
    Budget Speech 2018
    Business
    Business Budget
    Business Rescue
    Cadre Formation
    Carbon Tax
    Careers
    CEO
    Code Of Ethics
    Companies Act
    Constitution
    Continuing Professional Development
    CPA Ireland
    CPD
    Cryptocurrencies
    Cryptocurrency
    Cyber Crime
    Cyber Security
    Cyril Ramaphosa
    Darren Gorton
    David Van Rooyen
    Davis Commission
    Debt
    Debt Intervention Bill
    Deloitte
    Department Of Basic Education
    Department Of Home Affairs
    Die Hoërskool DF Malan
    Different Types Of Accountants
    Doctoral
    Economic Climate
    Economic Development
    Economic Growth
    Economic Instability
    Economy
    Education
    Empowerment
    Environment
    Estate Planning
    Ethics
    Ettiene Retief
    Exxcellence
    Faith Ngwenya
    Female Entrepreneurs
    FICA
    FICA Bill
    Finance Minister
    Financial Intelligence Centre Act
    Financial Statements
    Fiscus
    Foreign Trade
    Fraud
    Georgina Barrick
    Global Economy
    Government
    Government Institutions
    Grade 11
    Grade 12
    Grant Thornton
    Health Issues
    Honours Degree
    HSBC
    IFAC
    Initial Coin Offerings
    International Business Report
    International Federation Of Accountants
    International Standard Of Review Engagements
    IRC Of SA
    Job Creation
    Job Losses
    Juane Cronje
    KPMG
    Kwa-Zulu Natal
    Large Business Centre
    LBC
    Learners
    Legal
    Malusi Gigaba
    Mandela Day
    Mark Kingon
    Marnus Broodryk
    Masters Degree
    Mathematics
    Medium-Term Budget Policy Statement
    Membership
    Mid-term Budget
    Mini Budget
    Moetapele Programme
    Momorandum Of Understanding
    Money Launderers
    Monitoring Females
    MTBPS
    NAO
    National Accounting Olympiad
    National Budget 2017
    National Consumer Tribunal
    National Credit Amendment Bill
    National Credit Regulator
    National Development Plan
    National Health
    National Imperatives
    National Tax Thesis
    NOCLAR
    Non-compliance
    Non-Compliance With Laws And Regulations
    Norton Rose Fullbright
    Obesity
    PAFA
    Pan African Federation Of Accountants
    Parilament
    Parliament
    Parliament’s Trade And Industry Committee
    Passenger Identity
    Paying Taxes Report 2018
    PE Exam
    Personal Details
    Personal Income Tax
    Pravin Gordhan
    Prem Govender
    Professional Accountants
    Professional Accountant (SA)
    Professional Accounting
    Professional Evaluation Exam
    Project Achiever
    Project Achiever Extended
    Protection Of Information
    Public Schools
    PWC
    Ragiema Thokan Mahomed
    Ragiema Thokan-Mahomed
    Rashied Small
    Repositioning
    Retirement Funding Reform
    SAIPA
    SAIPA Budget Breakfast
    SARS
    School
    School Learners
    Service Delivery
    Shahid Daniels
    Shahied Daniels
    Shirley Olsen
    Sibusiso Thungo
    Skills
    Skills Development
    Skills Retention Plan
    Skills Shortage
    SMEs
    South Africa
    South African Institute Of Professional Accountants
    South African Institute Of Professional Accountants
    South African Institute Of Tax Professionals
    South African Schools Act
    Struggling Economy
    Students
    Sugar Tax
    Sugary Drinks
    Sustainibility
    Tax
    Tax & Accounting Thesis Competition
    Tax Administration Act
    Tax Administration Laws Amendment Bill
    Taxation
    Tax Clearance Certificates
    Tax Compliance
    Tax Filing Season
    Tax Indaba 2016
    Tax Law
    Tax Ombud
    Tax Payers
    Tax Practitioner
    Tax Season
    Tax Thesis
    Tax Thesis Competition
    Technology
    Tertiary Education
    The Financial Intelligence Centre Amendment (FIC
    Thesis/dissertations
    The South African Institute Of Professional Accountants
    The South African Revenue Service
    The Tax Administration Act
    Thomas Hoeppli
    Tom Mojane
    Transformation
    Treasury
    Trust
    Trusts
    UCT
    Unemployment
    University Of Cape Town
    Value Added Tax
    VAT
    Wealth Taxes
    Winslyn
    Women
    Women Empowerment
    Women's Month
    Workplace
    World Bank
    Xenophobia
    Youth
    Zobuzwe Ngobese

    RSS Feed

CONTACT US

office [at] atthatpoint [dot] co [dot] za
© COPYRIGHT 2020
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

  • home
  • services
  • about us
  • our work
  • our thoughts
  • SAIPA Newsroom